DPC Home
DPC Documents
DPC Hearings
Democrats.gov
 

Social Security Privatization: Still a Priority for Washington Republicans


July 28, 2006
DPC Staff Contact:

President Bush took the country in the wrong direction last year when he tried to privatize Social Security.  Despite widespread public opposition to his plan, and a broadly-held assumption that privatization is dead, Washington Republicans recently made it clear that they will continue to push for privatization after this year’s Congressional elections. 

 

As middle-class life becomes less affordable and pension plans less reliable, the last thing Americans need is a Republican scheme to make deep cuts in Social Security benefits and increase the national debt to finance risky private accounts.  Democrats are committed to a new direction that will strengthen Social Security and retirement security for all Americans.

 

 

WASHINGTON REPUBLICANS NOT GIVING UP ON PRIVATIZATION

 

As long as Bush is in power, he will not give up on privatizing Social Security.     “I addressed that issue last year, focusing on Social Security reform…If we can’t get it done this year, I’m going to try next year.  And if we can’t get it done next year, I’m going to try the year after that.” (President Bush, 6/27/06)

 

Republicans waiting until after November elections to resume privatization drive.   Because Washington Republicans know that Social Security privatization is unpopular, they are waiting until after the elections to pursue their plan in Congress.  Rep. Jim McCrery, the Republican Chairman of the House Ways and Means Subcommittee on Social Security, said, “I’m hopeful that next year will provide us an opportunity to kind of go back to square one, start all over and come up with a Social Security plan…We tried that last year – didn’t get very far…That’s an issue that simply is going to have to wait until after the elections.” (Gannett News Service, 6/9/06)  The Wall Street Journal reported that White House Chief of Staff Josh Bolten is “looking ahead to next year… trying to lay the groundwork for a renewed effort to reform Social Security.” (Wall Street Journal, 6/17/06) 

 

Social Security privatization will be top priority for Republican Congress in 2007.  “I think the president wants to do tax reform, and I’m certainly ready to help him do tax reform in ‘07 and ‘08…Looking at the lay of the land politically and substantively, it seems to me the more logical order would be Social Security, then tax reform, then healthcare reform.” (Rep. McCrery, CongressDaily, 6/6/06)

 

 

REPUBLICAN SNEAK ATTACKS ON SOCIAL SECURITY

 

Republican sneak attack on Social Security in the Budget Process Bill.

On June 20, 2006, on a party-line vote, the Senate Budget Committee approved S. 3521, a Republican bill to make major changes in federal budget laws.  While described by Republican proponents as a measure to restore fiscal discipline, the legislation actually represents a sneak attack on Social Security.  For example, the Republican Budget Process bill would create two commissions controlled by Republicans that could develop fast-tracked recommendations to privatize Social Security, with little public notice or debate.  The bill also would put Social Security back “on-budget,” allowing Social Security surpluses to be used to mask the true size of the budget deficit.  In addition, the bill would give the President new line-item veto powers, making it easier for him to eliminate improvements in Social Security benefits and cut funding to administer the Social Security program, without an adequate opportunity for public input and a full debate.

 

Republican sneak attack to privatize Social Security in the Budget Resolution.  Senate Republicans voted earlier this year to pave the way for private accounts.  The overwhelming majority of Senate Republicans voted for an amendment to this year’s budget resolution that would have established a reserve fund to facilitate the establishment of privatized accounts in Social Security. (Roll Call No. 68, 3/16/06, DeMint Amendment No. 3087). 

 

Republican sneak attack to privatize Social Security in the Mid-Session Review.  The Mid-Session Budget Review released by the White House Office of Management and Budget (OMB) earlier this month included a proposal that would spend $721 billion – nearly $10 billion more than originally planned in the President’s original Fiscal Year 2007 budget – to turn Social Security into a system of private accounts with lower guaranteed benefits. (Office of Management and Budget, Fiscal Year 2007 Mid-Session Review, 7/11/06)